Reading orders / Bookmarks

Bookmarks worth using

If you are forty books into Discworld, a receipt is not a bookmark. These are the stained glass ones we keep in rotation, sorted by what you read.

Stained glass bookmarksThey are not glass. That is the first thing to know, and the reason they work as bookmarks at …Dragon bookmarksIf you read epic fantasy, you own a dragon bookmark eventually. The question is which kind of …Dark academia bookmarksDark academia goes wrong when it tries too hard. The bookmarks that work look like something f…Gothic bookmarksGothic is the easiest aesthetic to overdo and the hardest to get right at two inches wide.Cat bookmarksThe highest-volume bookmark category there is, and the one with the most bad options in it.Fantasy bookmarksFantasy is the widest bookmark category and the one where matching the subgenre matters most.Celestial bookmarksCelestial designs are the one category where translucent acrylic genuinely beats paper, becaus…Gifts for book lovers under $10Do not buy a reader a book. You do not know what they have read, what they are mid-way through…

Six we would buy again

Across every theme, these are the ones still in use. Most come from Magical Bookmark Co, who sell the same designs on Etsy.

Miniature Magical Library Suncatcher Book Nook

A whole library in a page marker. The one that makes people ask where you got it.

Miniature Magical Library Suncatcher Book NookMiniature Magical Library Suncatcher Book Nook$7.99

Clever Raven Library Bookmark

Dark academia without the costume. Good for gothic and literary shelves.

Clever Raven Library BookmarkClever Raven Library Bookmark$8.99 on Etsy

Library Staircase Bookmark

Warm gold light. The one to pair with a slow reread.

Library Staircase BookmarkLibrary Staircase Bookmark$8.99

Grim Reaper Bookmark - Handcrafted Gothic…

For horror, Discworld, and anything with a body count.

Grim Reaper Bookmark - Handcrafted Gothic…Grim Reaper Bookmark - Handcrafted Gothic…$8.99 on Etsy

Dragon Stained Glass Bookmark

The default epic fantasy pick. Works for most doorstoppers.

Dragon Stained Glass BookmarkDragon Stained Glass Bookmark$8.99

Bookmark Protector Sleeve

Boring, and the smartest thing on the list. Buy one per bookmark.

Bookmark Protector SleeveBookmark Protector Sleeve$1.99 on Etsy

What to look for

Three things matter in a bookmark you use daily. It has to be thin enough not to crack the spine, stiff enough not to curl, and distinctive enough that you do not lose it in a stack. Stained glass acrylic hits all three, which is why it has taken over the bookish gift shelves.

The protector sleeve is the unglamorous one. Acrylic picks up scuffs if it rides loose in a bag, and the sleeve costs a few dollars against replacing a bookmark you liked.

If you want to go down the rabbit hole, there are a few hundred stained glass bookmark designs between that shop and its Etsy storefront.